Cookie Pre-Orders

Pre-orders are open Sunday through Wednesday each week. All cookie orders are freshly baked and will be ready for pickup Saturday of that same week. May be able to arrange pickup orders on Tuesdays in San Luis Obispo please email feelincrummybakery@gmail.com to inquire. Please note: Even though you place your order earlier in the week, pickups are only available on Saturdays. Thank you so much for supporting our small bakery!

Cookies

Simple ingredients. Big homemade flavor.

Featured

Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie

Our signature chocolate chip cookie starts with rich butter slowly browned to bring out deep, nutty caramel notes. We fold in generous pools of premium semisweet chocolate, a touch of brown sugar for chewiness, and a sprinkle of flaky sea salt to balance every bite. Also available without flaky sea salt if requested. Crisp at the edges, soft and gooey in the center, this elevated take on a classic cookie delivers warm, toasty flavor with melty chocolate in every bite. It’s comfort food—made unforgettable.

3 cookies

$10

6 cookies

$18

12 cookies

$34

24 cookies

$65

Brownie Cookie

All the decadence of a brownie, transformed into a perfectly portable cookie. This fudgy favorite is made with deep, dark cocoa for an intense chocolate base, then loaded with creamy white chocolate and rich semisweet chocolate chips for the ultimate contrast in flavor. Soft and chewy with crackly tops and melty chocolate in every bite, it’s a chocolate lover’s dream—bold, balanced, and irresistibly indulgent.

3 cookies

$10

6 cookies

$18

12 cookies

$34

24 cookies

$65

Variety Pack

Chocolate Chip and Brownie Cookie Variety pack.

6 cookies

$18

12 cookies

$34

24 cookies

$65

Bread

Melon Pan (Like a Concha)

Freshly baked milk bread Made with real butter Soft, fluffy bread with a crisp cookie topping.

2 Pack Regular

$8.50

2 pack Matcha

$9.50

2 pack Choco Chip

$9.50

4 Pack Regular

$16.50

4 Pack Matcha

$17.50

4 Pack Choco Chip

$17.50

6 Pack Regular

$24

6 Pack Matcha

$25

6 Choco Chip

$25

2 of each flavor

$25

Melon Pan & Cookies

Melon Pan and Chocolate chip or Brownie Cookie pack.

3 Melon Pan & 3 Chocolate Chip Cookies

$23

3 Melon Pan & 3 Brownie Cookies

$23

3 Matcha Pan & 3 Chocolate Chip Cookies

$24.50

3 Matcha Pan & 3 Brownie Cookies

$24.50

3 Chocolate Chip Pan & 3 Chocolate Chip Cookies

$24.50

3 Chocolate Chip Pan & 3 Brownie Cookies

$24.50

6 Melon Pan & 6 Chocolate Chip Cookies

$42

6 Melon Pan & 6 Brownie Cookies

$42

6 Matcha Pan & 6 Chocolate Chip Cookies

$43

6 Matcha Pan & 6 Brownie Cookies

$43

6 Chocolate Chip Pan & 6 Chocolate Chip Cookies

$43

6 Chocolate Chip Pan & 6 Brownie Cookies

$43